When I heard about The Lover's Dictionary, I wasn't sure that I was going to like it. It seemed to be one of those books that wasn't going to live up to the hype. The premise is definitely original. The book is written entirely in dictionary entries, with each word giving a window into the relationship between the narrator and his girlfriend. It sounds like an interesting premise, but I was worried that it was going to be too cute and clever to really work. I went into the book with trepidation, but I have to say that I was pleasantly surprised by how it turned out.
I think the strong point of this book is the honesty of the story and the clever way that the author used the format to enhance that story. Because the dictionary entries are in alphabetical order rather than being arranged chronologically, the story is disjointed and non-linear. This means that the reader discovers the story bit by bit, piecing together a relationship from glimpses of moments and feelings relayed out of order or context. I feel like this gives the story a sense of suspense and forward motion. Some entries will pick up where earlier entries left off, filling in gaps and changing the story from one page to the next. The way he would repeat and elaborate on conversations that he had mentioned earlier was very effective in both keeping the book moving forward and in creating a sense of unity throughout and otherwise fragmented book. I also think the fragmentation comes across as a very honest way to portray memory. When looking back over the course of a relationship, I don't usually see things in perfect chronological order. My memories are a kaleidoscope of the best and worst times, of turning points and everyday moments that come together into some kind of coherent whole. I think the format of the book is a good way of showing that remembering process.
The Lover's Dictionary book was a very short read. I read it in the course of a few hours on a lazy summer afternoon. Despite what I said in my previous paragraph, it isn't a particularly heavy book. Instead, I like to think of it as a great summer read. Because of all the short entries, it's great for reading on a day when you may have only a few minutes here and there. The writing style, while both pleasing and intelligent, is also very readable. If books were films, this book would be a mini-series. It's broken up into convenient episodes and it isn't too difficult to understand. That said, this book isn't fluffy or silly. It is probably one of the most intelligent and realistic "easy summer reads" I've recommended. Levithan has somehow managed to make a quality work that still qualifies as easy and enjoyable. If you are having the kind of lazy summer I've been having, but you still want a book that isn't going to insult you, I would definitely recommend The Lover's Dictionary.
Rating: Recommended
A short but intelligent read that, while it won't change your life, is definitely worth your time.

I love the premise of this book.
ReplyDeleteSlightly different (but it popped into my head) so I think you might like: A History of the Heart by a Norwegian scholar Ole M. Høystad. It examines the cultural, sociological, artistic and historical representation of the organ. It's fascinating.
Thanks for giving me an Emily fix :)
I keep seeing positive reviews about this book and I can't decide if I should read it... A few years ago I read An Encyclopedia of Love by M. Scheil, which is set up pretty much the same way. I remember liking it until I got used to the strangeness of the format - after that it became tedious. Would the Lover's Dictionary be worth reading without the feeling of newness that comes with the dictionary style?
ReplyDeleteI'd mostly ignored reviews of this book until recently but now I'm thinking it definitely sounds like something worth picking up. Sounds really fantastic and I love the way it shows the disjointedness of memories and etc.
ReplyDeleteThis sounds like just the kind of book I'd like. I'll definitely put it on my to-read list.
ReplyDeleteDeborah: That sounds like a really interesting book. I'll have to see if I can find a copy somewhere. Thanks for convincing me to finally write something!
ReplyDeleteRayna: I think it's still worth reading even if you're used to the style. First of all, it's a pretty short book, so by the time you get used to it the book is basically over. Also, I found the emotions in the book to be very honest and touching, which is something that I really enjoy no matter what the format is. Some of the writing is really pretty too, so that helps.
Amy: I ignored it for a long time too, even though I read a bunch of positive reviews. I'm glad I eventually picked it up. It was fun.
Karen: You'll have to let me know what you think. :)